ClaudeIn our password test, it wrote working code, explained each check step by step and added test examples. It also gave a sensible tip about long passphrases. Great if you want to understand the code, not just copy it. | Writing codeClaude winsFor anyone who asks AI to write code from a description | GitHub CopilotWrote working, compact code too, and opened it in a side panel ready to copy. But we asked for a simple explanation and got a single line. Fine if you already know what the code does and just need it written. |
|---|
ClaudeFound the bug in our JavaScript test right away, fixed it and explained why it broke. It added two useful tips: a shorter way to write the loop and a warning about prices that arrive as text. | Fixing bugsTieFor anyone stuck on an error | GitHub CopilotFound the same bug and fixed it in two short sentences, with the corrected code in a side panel. No extras, which is perfect when you just want the fix and want to get back to work quickly. |
|---|
ClaudeExplained our email-checking code piece by piece, with six examples of what passes and fails and honest limits. A beginner could follow it without looking anything up. Of the two, it's clearly the better teacher. | Explaining codeClaude winsFor beginners and anyone reading someone else's code | GitHub CopilotGave a short, correct explanation of each part of the pattern, with one example. Clear enough if you already know a little code, but a beginner may need to ask a follow-up question or two before it clicks. |
|---|
ClaudeClaude Code works in VS Code, JetBrains, the terminal and the web, but it needs Claude Pro. It works more like a helper you hand tasks to than a tool that suggests code while you type. | In your editorGitHub Copilot winsFor people who code in VS Code, JetBrains or on GitHub | GitHub CopilotLives inside VS Code, JetBrains and GitHub and suggests code as you type, even on the free plan with 2,000 completions a month. It feels like part of the editor, so you barely notice you're using AI. |
|---|
ClaudeClaude Code plans a task, edits many files, runs the tests and checks its own work. Many developers on Reddit say it's steadier on big jobs. You describe the goal, then review the result at the end. | Big tasksClaude winsFor bigger changes across many files | GitHub CopilotHas agents and a command-line tool too, and they've improved a lot. Some developers find them less steady than Claude Code on long, multi-file jobs, but they're fine for smaller, well-defined changes, especially inside GitHub. |
|---|
ClaudeUses only Claude's own models: Sonnet, Opus and, on higher plans, Fable. They're strong for coding, but if you want to try another company's model on a task, you'll need a different tool for that. | Model choiceGitHub Copilot winsFor people who like to pick the AI model | GitHub CopilotOn paid plans you can pick the model, including Claude Sonnet 5.5 and Opus 5.5, OpenAI's models and more. The free plan uses Auto, which picks for you. Handy if you like to switch models per task. |
|---|
ClaudeThe free Claude chat helps with code, as our tests showed, with limits that reset every few hours. But Claude Code, the tool that works on whole projects, isn't included in the free plan. You need Pro for that. | Free planGitHub Copilot winsFor anyone who won't pay | GitHub CopilotFree gives you 2,000 code completions a month in your editor, plus some chat and agent use. That's real coding help for $0, and verified students can get Copilot Student at no cost. A strong free plan for coders. |
|---|
ClaudeClaude Code comes with Pro at $20 a month, or $17 if you pay yearly. Max ($100) and Ultra ($200) are for developers who use it all day. You also get Claude's chat, Research and app connections. | PriceGitHub Copilot winsFor anyone choosing one paid plan | GitHub CopilotPro costs $10 a month, with unlimited completions and $15 of AI use. Pro+ is $39 and Max $100 for heavier use. For teams, Business is $19 and Enterprise $39 per user a month. It's the cheaper way to start. |
|---|